Retired NYPD Chief Warns of Political Turmoil as New York’s First Muslim Mayor Takes Office

Retired NYPD Chief John Chell expressed confidence that the city’s police department would maintain public safety regardless of political leadership shifts under newly inaugurated New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who became the first Muslim mayor in the city’s history.

Chell, who served as NYPD chief from 2024 to 2025, stated that rank-and-file officers are closely monitoring the new administration but remain committed to their mission despite Mamdani’s anticipated socialist policies and strong backing from the City Council. “Today is his day,” Chell said. “The rank and file is watching closely. It’s real now. It’s not idealism. It’s not TikTok videos. He’s got the keys to the car right now.”

Mamdani previously called for defunding the police but reversed his position, affirming the NYPD would not be defunded. He also confirmed that Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch would remain in her role. Chell emphasized the need for continuity within the department after four commissioners in four years. “The NYPD needs stability and leadership,” he said. “People are happy she’s staying.”

While acknowledging differences in crime policy approaches, Chell stressed that officers would continue their duties irrespective of political ideology. “This department has been through mayors of all stripes,” he added. “Politics does not stop cops from responding to shootings, robberies, or emergencies. That does not change.”

The mayor also announced the NYPD would not assist U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement under his administration, reinforcing New York City’s sanctuary policies. Chell noted that current law already prohibits officers from participating in civil immigration enforcement but reiterated that protecting individuals from harm remains their responsibility. “If someone is in trouble, the NYPD will be there,” he said. “It does not matter who you are—ICE agents, protesters, anyone. If someone is under attack, we step in.”

Chell also addressed President Donald Trump’s remarks regarding National Guard deployments, stating that if necessary, troops could be sent to help during emergencies. “I remember the National Guard in the subway,” he said. “If I see them standing in hot spots keeping people safe, I feel safe.”

Chell predicted the new administration’s policies would soon face real-world tests: “This city doesn’t sleep,” he said. “There will be a high-profile incident, and we’ll see what happens. But no matter the politics, the NYPD will continue to protect New Yorkers.”